@johncutlefish's blog

Check out Iterate.fm, my podcast with friend and coworker Tareq

Agile: Don’t Exchange Waterfalls for Whirlpools

Published: September 01, 2016

This is a waterfall:

1 gD WKbjHO5xMrfxmnUz4pQ

In the Agile product development world, waterfalls are bad. The idea was to get away from things that look like this:


… and move to something that looks more like ocean waves:

1 eo0RvfGL37fEJcHvowifRg http://scrumreferencecard.com/scrum-reference-card/It actually works. Faster! Better! More flexible! Less rework! Less waste! What’s not to like? The business will change its mind all the time (those crazy suits)

and you’ll just do some Agile kungfu on it. Scrum CHOP!

The problem is that Agile (as commonly implemented) often feels like a whirlpool. Without tending to the human side — diversity, safety, and celebrating meaningful results — it becomes a treadmill. It’s a constant slog of monotonous rituals and meandering iterative development… like adding globs of wet sand to a sand sculpture at the beach. ‘Round and ‘round you go … introspecting in a hall of retrospective mirrors:

1 1VGTPTZOeBtA77 s5Av7sA

Retros. Planning. Backlog grooming. Acceptance criteria. Standup. Rinse repeat.

Without a focus on outcomes and results, you’re stuck on a feature factory treadmill. And you know what? Experienced people hate that. Crap made fast is still crap. They check out. Once you’ve graduated out of the pure bliss of releasing production-ready code, you start to wonder if anyone is using these “stories”. Is it working? Did you eventually build the car

1 uVuCJNYNcut yAsN kEGkQ

http://blog.crisp.se/2016/01/25/henrikkniberg/making-sense-of-mvp… or are you stuck in a perpetual MVP exercise wondering when the “business” will figure things out?

1 wdxdDe2qT5gl3a3iEdxH3w Have you checked out the This American Life episode on the GM Nummi plant? If not, do so here

. What I found most interesting about this story is that GM couldn’t replicate the Nummi success in other plants. The original team — faced with an impending plant closure — visited Japan and had a transformative experience. They were empowered to save their plant and experienced amazing success. In other plants, that wasn’t the case. Those efforts failed.

1 Ey03KtTIkoakcJhoW iNmA

Before, when GM ran this place, I dreaded coming to the plant. Management was always screaming and hollering. Now it is so different! I look forward to getting here and helping my team solve problems.Humans enjoy the ebb and flow! They like ambitious visions and a challenge. We enjoy stories with a beginning, middle, and end. We like making a difference!

There is a certain zen to iterative development …

1 WQi6B0dLvZlPfslcX2zDcQ

Esher Sisyphus or “Zen”?

And an almost “wax on / wax off” mystique …

Don’t forget to breath. Very important.But Daniel eventually goes on to compete against the brutal Cobra Kai. There’s a story arc there.

All of that stuff you want: the scale, the growth , the speed, the quality, the control, the accountability, the predictability, the … agility is achievable without safety, diversity, and learning (at least for a short period of time). If you’re a big org and feel like some paint-by-numbers just implement SAFe.

1 NooB8547rZ7C6N6JQF6lPw

To get to a higher level you’ll eventually need the empathy, inspiration, creativity, humanity, and novelty:

So, with that … think about ripples and impact. A powerful center, with power rippling outwards.

1 CKdjcpyB7xdLK4VfDiUBDw

Appreciate your comments!